Graphic Enterprises - Home of The Pioneer Times a Web News site about Re-Enacting and Living History

Editorial Views

As a web news service the editors of The Pioneer Times often have editorial opinions on the news and events that we cover. We also accept guest editorials from our readers.

Suppose they gave a reenactment
 and no spectators came?

By Charles Hayes

Suppose they gave a reenactment and no spectators came?  What if 100 serious, dedicated re-enactors showed up with clothing and accoutrements that they had invested hundreds of hours of research and work into and there was no one to see it but other re-enactors?

I know some re-enactors who salivate at the thought of restricted events.  I will go so far as to say that I have attended several such events and have tried to keep pictures period-authentic when there were spectators. I had a wonderful time at restricted events.   The fact that I had a wonderful time, however, means nothing.  I had a wonderful time living in a tent two miles from Balikasher, Turkey.  I have a better time when I am simultaneously living in yesterday and touching tomorrow. 

Like good teachers, re-enactors can profoundly affect young people.   We can (and do) demonstrate a lifestyle that their video games and mall experiences cannot touch.   The smart alecky sixth grader I knew from a middle school was in absolute awe of the re-enactors at the 2006 Battle of Blue Licks event. He asked more questions and displayed more curiosity than I had ever seen him display in a classroom at Bryan Station Middle School.  He wasn't worried about appearing ``cool" or disinterested.  His interest shined like a lighthouse beacon in the darkest night and he was amazed that the basis of our knowledge was books. 

We re-enactors have had a mission thrust upon us.  In a world when many educators and politicians use the shield of political correctness to protect them from reality, we are historically correct. I will emphasize that most of us are historically correct and proud of it.   We, and our interaction with spectators, may be the deciding factor in bringing an interest in history to a young person.  

This occurred in one of my classes while I was student teaching in May, 1999.   The subject was world civilization and the topic was the American Revolution.  I took my Continental Army uniform and several accoutrements to the classroom.  After the students examined the items, a young man asked to wear the coat.  I let him wear the coat and began the lesson.  His hand was constantly in the air when I asked questions. This C student began making A's in world civilization.

At re-enactments, we are a strong opposition to the segment of education and society that is attempting to eradicate history and tradition from American life and American education ------ and we have our work cut out for us. The Berea community school system stopped having Christmas Parties and began having holiday parties several years ago.  I was informed by the principal that Christmas is not compatible with cultural diversity.

The diluting of American history in the school setting is meant to spread diversity and adhere to political correctness rather than to teach history to tradition and celebrate our democracy.   Anyone who thinks that I am exaggerating need only look to the Enola Gay exhibit in the Smithsonian Museum.   Before Veterans' groups became involved, the exhibit was anti-American. It focused on the theory that the United States started the war with Japan and unnecessarily used atomic weapons on Japan.  When public pressure changed the exhibit, the history PhD assembling the original exhibit stated that the change did not matter because he, and those who think like him, were writing the textbooks and the standardized tests.

Another motivation re-enactors have for leaving spectators smiling is that many of our re-enactments are supported by the state and if no spectators come, the state has no reason to continue support. I have been to re-enactments that have state support and many that didn't.  Re-enactments with state support are more affordable.

Ways that we re-enactors can counter this influence are:

    · Bring extra hats and accoutrements to events and allow young people to wear or hold them while having their picture taken.

    · Pose with spectators ---- If someone is taking your picture, ask them to join you or your group and have someone else take the picture with them in the picture.

    · Answer questions

    · Take a little time to meet them. This doesn't have to be anything formal or time consuming. I like to walk down the line of spectators before an event starts.   This gives them a chance to take pictures and ask questions.

    · Listen as the spectators reveal they are the direct descendant of Pocahontas.   Rather than contradict them, suggest they might like to read a biography (which will show she died childless).

Hayes poses with a spectator at Fort Boonesborough.

This German hausfrau fires a rifle (a flintlock) for the first time,  near Rhodenbach, Germany.

Re-enactors at the opening of the Cumberland Gap Tunnel, October 1996.

If they take your picture or ask to take your picture, invite them to get in the picture with you.

Social interaction with spectators pays big dividends. We were invited back to this fest.

Three Air force personnel go over the notes, for their first living history presentation, with MSgt. Hayes.

Introduce others to re-enacting. Only two in this group had re-enacting experience.

    · Make yourself available at schools and activities in your own community.

    Re-enactors can profoundly affect  young people.   Let's do it.

Charles
Hayes

Charles Hayes is a frequent re-enactor at the Battle of Blue Licks where he portrayed Hugh McGary in 2007 and at the Siege of Fort Boonesborough.

He also has contributed photos to this site from Fort Boonesborough's Woodsman's Weekend and on the Guest Gallery - of both Civil War and Revolutionary War era events.

24 Years in the Air Force didn't stop Hayes from Re-Enacting - it simply gave him more venues.

On What Makes a Good Event?

by Kathy Cummings

I think all events have the potential of being great events? But I do think re-enactors can make or break an event by their comments. ``Did  you hear that ......"

And frankly being on the organizing end of several events -  it's a scary proposition. Let's face it - like all folks re-enactors have their cliques, their special friends, groups that are ``more PC" than other groups.  But the bottom line is why are we re-enactors. If it is for the love of history  and our goal is to educate the public - can't we be a little kinder to each other.

How many times have you heard...."we're not going there because  last year so and so didn't ......" and on and on. Let's face it. Most events are  put on by strictly volunteer groups. Everybody gives freely of their time and energy. And some times people get cross. Patience wears thin and the next thing  you know an event is no longer on the ``must attend list."

I also think as re-enacting becomes more and more popular  - new events spring up. One look at Smoke and Fire will assure you that you could  be on the move every weekend. So folks do pick and choose - coordinate family and work schedules and see what they can attend. And organizers move events and change plans to try and get a weekend that doesn't conflict with another event.

But I am asking LET'S ALL BE FAIR TO ONE ANOTHER. Look at your schedule, coordinate your plans and attend what and where you can. But let's not bad mouth (and in essence boycott) events because someone spoke out of turn. Or  because you couldn't pitch your tent in the spot you wanted. Planning events is a tricky business. It takes many, many volunteer hours. If you have an issue with an event - talk to the event coordinators. Tell them of your concerns. Ask  for changes. And most of all give them a second chance. But don't go around  encouraging all your cronies to skip an event because things didn't go your way.

Till the next event... (I hear it's going to be great!)

C

The Photo Gallery of Events

Living History Events - 18th Century

Living History Events - 19th Century

Civil War Era

Time Line Events

Indoor Trade Events

Museums, Workshops, Schools & Other Events

All material contained in this site is © 2003-2007 Graphic Enterprises.